Monday, September 30, 2013

No more star ratings?


"I tell people I'm okay with it. But, I'm really not."

  Have you watched the latest Big Bang Theory yet? The Season 7 just came out last week! If you are a big fan like me I bet you have already seen it. Sheldon Cooper said something about Social Media in Episode One: Sheldon told Penny about something that he would take to the grave. "A while back, YouTube changedits user-interface from a star-base rating system to a thumbs-up rating system.I tell people I'm okay with it. But, I'm really not."



  No more star ratings on YouTube? Yes, it started since 2010.



   YouTube post an announcement about the changes they did. Here is what they wrote about the star-base rating system. "Simplified binary ratings: As we noted in an earlier blog post, the rating system on YouTube doesn't really work that well (e.g. only the 1 and 5 star ratings were ever really used). So we moved towards a simpler "Like / Don't Like" model. Liking a video will also save it to your Favorites to make it easy to find those videos again. " 
star rating system 
thumb-up system









  I started to do research about this. The star rating system offer people accurate information about how much they like the video on YouTube. YouTube let people rate by giving stars - one star for when you loathe something, five for when you love it. Now the “Thumb-Up” system only gives you options to like it or not. Obviously you can’t tell how much people like that one by only “Like”. 


  I looked at Apple Store and Yelp and they are still using the star rating system and they do a really good job. Apple Store allows everyone who has already downloaded and used the app to give ratings on that one and you can write a brief comment if you want. So people who wants to download an app can clearly see how many people have downloaded this one already and how much they like this one according to the star scores this one earned. The system is working pretty much like this on Yelp too. I noticed that those two are receiving positive comments on because of the star rating system. People get more accurate information and more details from star ratings in a short time, they love it.
Apple Store
    
Yelp.com 

  YouTube thought a thumbs up/thumbs down should be more effective. But actually people do love the ratings more because the ratings help people to show more personal feelings. Yes, “Like” is a feeling too, but the stars give you four more options than only one. If there is one way you can get more trust from people is let them“speak”. The star ratings used to be an effective way people “speak”, they “speak” by those golden shining little stars. It is really not cool by no more ratings. I am totally agree with Sheldon “I tell people I am okay with it. But, I am really not.”

    




 

2 comments:

  1. I quite agree with your opinion that folks prefer star ratings rather than thumbs up or down because the more specific comments by people will make us trust this information better and let us have a good standard to compare with other counterparts. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Star rating gives us options. As example I like a video but not really much maybe just for 2 stars but definitely wouldn't give thumbs-up. The new system pushes on us. It is like they took my right to choose.

    ReplyDelete